Apple Watch: The Choice Everyone Makes Wrong
Apple Watch 8 or Ultra. Bigger screen. Longer battery life. More robust design. You think the choice is simple: if you're an adventurer, choose the Ultra. If you're a casual user, the 8 will suffice. But this is where most buyers make a mistake . Because the real difference isn't in those specs. It's in what you don't use .
That dive computer in the Ultra? That extra battery life? Most people use their smartwatch for notifications, step counting, and occasionally checking their heart rate. Period. For those basic features, you'll pay hundreds of euros extra with the Ultra. While you could have spent that money on smart accessories you actually use every day. Or you could delve into the world of Apple Intelligence for real productivity gains . That's why the question isn't which watch is best, but which features you actually need.
Useful links
The practical differences that really matter
The choice between an Apple Watch 8 and Ultra seems simple on paper. Yet, many buyers make the same mistake: they're swayed by specs they'll never use. So let's discuss the real differences that will impact your daily use.
Screen size and readability
The Ultra has a 49mm case compared to the Series 8's 41mm or 45mm. This not only means a larger screen, but also a completely different wearing experience. For those with narrow wrists, the Ultra often feels uncomfortably large. The extra screen real estate is nice for reading messages, but for quick notifications, it makes little difference.
The brightness does differ significantly. With 2000 nits of peak brightness compared to 1000 nits on the Series 8, the Ultra screen is perfectly readable even in bright sunlight. However, for indoor use or normal outdoor conditions, this difference is barely noticeable.
Battery life in practice
Apple promises up to 36 hours of battery life under normal use for the Ultra, compared to 18 hours for the Series 8. In practice, this means you can easily get two days of use without recharging the Ultra. The Series 8 needs to be charged every night.
But there's a catch. Many people charge their watch every night anyway, often next to their phone. That adds hundreds of euros to the battery life you don't use. Only on multi-day trips without a charging option, or when you use sleep tracking intensively, does this difference really matter.
Specific functions under scrutiny
Sports functions and sensors
Both models feature:
- Heart rate monitor and ECG function
- Blood oxygen sensor (SpO2)
- GPS tracking for workouts
- Fall detection and crash detection
- Water resistance up to 50 meters (Series 8) or 100 meters (Ultra)
The Ultra adds some niche features here:
- Depth gauge for diving up to 40 meters
- 86 decibel siren for emergency situations
- Dual GPS frequency for more accurate tracking in cities
- Night vision mode with red screen
For the average athlete who runs, cycles, or goes to the gym, the Series 8 offers all the necessary features. The Ultra's extras are especially relevant for extreme sports or professional athletes.
Daily use and comfort
Weight plays a bigger role than many people think. The Ultra weighs about 61 grams, while the aluminum Series 8 weighs around 38 grams. You'll feel this difference all day long, especially while typing or exercising.
The action button on the Ultra seems handy, but in practice, most people rarely use it. You can assign it to one function, like starting a workout or finding your phone. Nice, but not essential.
Price differences and alternatives
A new Apple Watch Ultra costs at least €899, while the Series 8 starts at €499. For that €400 price difference, you can, for example:
- Buying a refurbished iPad for productivity
- Arrange multiple years of AppleCare+ coverage
- Buy a complete set of accessories, including extra straps and a wireless charger
A smart option is to consider a refurbished model. A refurbished Apple Watch Series 8 offers the same functionality at a lower price. These devices have been professionally inspected and cleaned, and are often indistinguishable from new.
Use cases: who chooses what?
Choose the Series 8 if you:
- Mainly want to track notifications, fitness and health
- Looking for a comfortable, lightweight watch for everyday use?
- Values a good price-quality ratio
- Have a smaller wrist or value elegance over robustness
- Would you rather spend your budget on other Apple products or accessories?
Choose the Ultra if you:
- Regularly practices extreme sports (mountain climbing, diving, ultra-trails)
- Spending multiple days without charging
- The extra bright screen you need for working in bright sunlight
- Appreciate the robust look and have a larger wrist
- Have the budget and want all possible features
Practical considerations for the long term
Also consider the lifespan of your investment. Both models receive at least five years of software updates. The difference in build quality means the Ultra will likely last longer with heavy use, but for regular use, the Series 8 is also very durable.
Resale value is another factor. The Ultra may retain its value better due to its higher purchase price and niche market. However, the Series 8 has a larger target audience on the used market.
Straps are interchangeable between all modern Apple Watch models, so you can still use your existing collection. Note that the Ultra only fits 49mm straps, while the Series 8 offers a choice of 41mm or 45mm.
Conclusion: make a conscious choice
For most people, the Apple Watch Series 8 is more than enough. This model offers all the essential smartwatch features without any unnecessary bells and whistles. The money you save can be better invested in other products or accessories you use daily.
The Ultra is a specialized product for a specific target group. If you're unsure whether you need the extra features, the answer is probably no. Only when you have concrete use cases for the unique features will the extra price be justified.
Also consider a refurbished model for the best value. You'll get the same functionality, with a warranty, at a more attractive price. This way, you'll make a sustainable choice without compromising on quality.
The simple truth about smartwatch choices
Ultimately, the choice is simpler than you think. For 95% of users, the Apple Watch Series 8 is more than sufficient—you get all the essential health and fitness features without the burden of extreme sports functions that gather dust. Don't be seduced by specs that sound impressive but remain unused in practice.
Save yourself hundreds of euros and consciously choose what you truly need. A refurbished Series 8 is a smart option: the same quality, a better price, and you're making a more sustainable choice .
